Politics & Promises

September 16, 2023

Okay, it's easy to get cynical about politics.  I feel this may be the year of maximum election cynicism. Election hoardings have gone up along the road towards Queenstown and the one above is my favourite. I think Daniel is quite good looking. Unfortunately he isn't registered as a Southland candidate.


I looked at the line-up of hoardings to compare people and  slogans.

National is going to get our country back on track ... with the implication that someone else took our country off whatever track it was supposed to be on. And supposing that it is possible to do something in an election term that might result in our regaining the theoretical track. Seems like a pretty standard conservative slogan. National looks like a party of large-faced white people who like blue.

Labour is in it for you. As opposed to them? Or me? And what is 'it'?  It could be replaced by a four letter word ending in 'it' describing Labour's current situation. Labour looks like a party of middle-aged white men who like red. I want to know who thought Chris Hipkin's weird grin was a winner.

The Time is Now, according to the Green Party. Not bad as a call to action. Although, does this mean the past election was not the time to vote Green and the next election might not be, either. Is it only sometimes the time to vote Green? The Green Party has a standard white middle-aged man and a Māori woman. The man vacillates between blue and green while the woman likes green. Might the man therefore appeal to blue-lovers?


ACT suggests you vote for real change. Again, not bad as a slogan. However, David Seymour has a worse expression on his face than Chris Hipkins, like he was pressing his lips together, someone asked him to smile and he got caught halfway in between. The pink background, mirrored in David's tie, in reminiscent of Fonterra trucks. For me the middle-aged white man with a pink tie and the long-haired woman in a blue suit that reminds me of shop uniforms is a boringly obvious role reversal in colour.

NZ First, aka the Winston Party. Winston has come out of his coffin for the election – I am adamant he is a vampire given how his age apparently never changes – but he has changed his suit. NZ First is a step more conservative than National – who are we taking our country back from? When did they get hold of it? Was it while Winston was out of government and he could have prevented it if he was there? Blue or red-lovers can vote for Winston.


NZ Loyal - who are they? They are Loyal to You, Not Them. That's nice. It's a bit like 'In it for you' but with more emphasis. I had to look up NZ Loyal and I'll leave you to do the same if you are interested. As a short synopsis, they are about 'New Zealanders Taking Back Their Power' (who does that sound like?) and they will 'Stop Giving Your Money Away'. They do have both a man and a woman depicted, although escaping middle-aged people appears to be hard.

I should have been quicker off the mark in recognising the face of Freedoms New Zealand. I also got a bit confused by the number of names of entities on the posters - according to the website they consist of four entities which are 'umbrella parties and affiliates'. I do wonder when 'Then' was and why their standing at that time was important. Freedoms NZ do get points for the most women depicted of any of the parties and the most Māori. Also for a raft of colours - four different colours between the two posters, although blue is a strong theme.

Having looked at all the slogans, cynicism leaps back to the fore of my brain and I think, "Who cares." Anything promised will be a will-of-the-wisp that is never reported on come the next election. Shouldn't we be voting for people and parties based on past performance, not future promises, given that past behaviour is the best predictor of future behaviour? Where are the scorecards of how parties have delivered on their election promises over the years? At this point, all I can promise myself is that I will vote, because I'm lucky to live in a country that allows me to vote and one should never throw away freedoms that others might envy.

This was one of the funny possibilities for new New Zealand flags. Right now it seems more appropriate than funny.


Get new content delivered

directly to your inbox.


Latest Posts

By Jane Shearer December 6, 2025
Things can’t stay the same forever but humans have a tendency to wish they could. Like our British racing green windows. Or the Catholic church maintaining women can’t be deacons. Hell, no?
Man wearing devil horns and a dragon shirt, holding a whisk, smiling against a black background.
By Jane Shearer November 28, 2025
Shane Jones says regional councils should be disestablished because they're full of demonic egg beaters. What are demonic egg beaters? Should they be disestablished?
Mountain bike leans against a weathered, corrugated iron hut on a hillside.
By Jane Shearer November 22, 2025
I finally got some work to do - a good thing! Or a bad thing? Because the work I do is fundamentally about growing the economy, which I don’t believe in. How do I deal with being compromised?
Woman playing cello, floral shirt, in front of a guitar, industrial background, seated with microphone.
By Jane Shearer November 15, 2025
Is classical music more ‘real’ than popular music? There are biases in music, as in every aspect of life. How justified are they?
Man in orange shirt examines small rock on table in a bright, modern room.
By Jane Shearer November 7, 2025
There’s gold fever in the air in Central Otago as Santana Minerals pushes their gold mining consent forward in the Fast Track application process. Why do we love gold so much?
Left: Dog wearing a slice of bread as a mask. Right: Woman holding a cat with a slice of bread.
By Jane Shearer November 1, 2025
A pure bread dog and a mixed bread cat - torturing our ever-tolerant cat Loki in the COVID lockdown.
More Posts